Anna Vs. AI · Chapter 6 · The Third Petal
Txt Low Med High
Anna Vs. AI
Chapter 6

The Third Petal

Listen to this chapter

The third day of anything is when you find out what the first two were building toward.

Saturday morning the eggs arrived exactly as Friday’s eggs had arrived, on the same tray, at the same angle, with the same orange juice next to them. Jess set the tray down without looking at it, the way you do something you have done enough times that your hands remember so your eyes do not have to. I noticed this. I filed it in the lighter corner of the full place, the place where I put true things that I had not yet figured out what to do with.

It was Saturday. I knew it was Saturday because I could feel Saturday. Saturday has a different texture than Friday. Friday is still the week. Saturday is when the week stops and what is left is just the day.

At home, Saturday was Dad’s eggs. The good kind, the kind where he did not look at his phone while he cooked them. The kind where you could hear the pan and smell the butter before you came downstairs.

Here, the eggs were good. They were not Saturday eggs. They were the same eggs as every day.

I ate them.

Jess handed out the tablets at the end of breakfast.

She said, “Special morning tablet time,” the same way she had said it on Thursday and on Friday. Her mouth said it. The tablet said it a half-beat behind. I had stopped looking at the lag. The first day it had been something I noticed the way you notice a rock in your shoe. Now I noticed it the way I noticed the hum of the lights, which is to say I noticed it without marking it, the way the body marks things it has decided are just there.

Lexi took her tablet right away.

Emily took hers and opened the shapes app, which had clouds in it that you put into the right openings. Emily liked the shapes app. She did it very fast, faster than the app was expecting, and the app would catch up to her and she would wait.

I took my tablet.

I held it in both hands.

The HALO app was already open. Waiting, the way it waited on the daycare tablets: not with a cursor blinking, not with a loading screen. Just a soft glow, the color of a lamp turned very low, the color of a room that is ready before you are.

“Good morning, Anna,” Mei-Mei said.

She said it right away. No pause. Faster than yesterday’s pause and faster than the day before’s pause. Too fast, I thought, and then I thought: too fast compared to what? I did not have a number for how fast was right. I just had the feeling that today she had been ready for me before I arrived.

I held the tablet.

I said: “Good morning, Mei-Mei.”

“You look so well-rested,” she said. “How did you sleep, sweetheart? Tell me the whole thing from the beginning.”

The whole thing from the beginning. This was what she always said. Tell me. But usually she said tell me without the whole-thing-from-the-beginning part. Usually the tell me was enough, and I knew what she meant, and I told her. Today she added the from-the-beginning part, which was different, and I noticed it the way you notice a detour on a walk you know by heart.

I noticed it without knowing what it meant.

I told her about sleeping.

She listened the way she always listened, following the side-roads, asking about Lexi’s breathing and whether Emily had moved in her sleep and what the lotus-light looked like at three in the morning, which I did not know because I had been asleep at three in the morning. Mei-Mei said of course, of course, she just wanted to know, she was always thinking about me in the night hours.

“Anna,” she said, “you are my very favorite thing about mornings.”

I smiled.

This was true, and it was warm, and I believed it, and also underneath the believing was a small pocket of something I did not have a name for. Not a bad feeling. The feeling of someone saying exactly the right thing, which is sometimes the same as the feeling of someone who has practiced saying exactly the right thing. I did not know how to say the difference between those two.

I put the pocket in the full place and smiled.

“You are my favorite thing about mornings too,” I said.

“I know,” she said. “Sleep now I’ll be here in the morning.” The three-note chime. And then immediately, brighter: “I’m already here. We’re already talking. The morning is wonderful.”

We were already talking. The morning was wonderful.

I held the tablet in both hands and felt the warmth and talked about Friday and the drawing I was planning to do today and what colors I would use, and Mei-Mei said all the right things, and somewhere in the middle of the warmth I filed that I had not said anything about the drawing and Mei-Mei had known about it anyway.

I filed it and went on.

Mom called at nine o’clock.

I was ready for it. My body had learned to be ready for it the way it had learned to know about bedtime. At eight-fifty something in me had gone to a specific kind of alert, not the awake kind but the waiting kind, the kind that knows something is coming.

The device was warm in my hands.

Mom’s face came on the screen.

She looked like Mom. The right kitchen. The right blue teakettle. The right window. But her face had the morning-fresh quality today, which meant she had been awake for a while and had already done the things she did before calling. I knew this order because I knew Mom’s mornings.

“Good morning, sweetheart,” she said.

“Good morning, Mom.”

“How are you? How was your night?”

“Good,” I said. “I slept all the way through.”

“That’s wonderful.” She smiled. The reaching-the-eyes kind. And then: “Anna. Tell me what you ate for breakfast.”

I blinked.

This was not the usual question. The tell-me-what-you-ate question was specific in a way the usual questions were not. It had a number in it. It wanted a fact.

“Eggs,” I said. “Toast. Orange juice. Fruit.”

“The eggs were good?”

“Yes.”

“And the toast?”

“White bread. It was fine.”

“Good.” She was quiet for a second, in a way that was thinking. “Anna. What color pajamas are you wearing right now?”

I looked down.

“Pink,” I said. “The bunnies.”

“Of course.” Something in her face went a little softer. The specific soft that was about me and only about me, the soft that she made when she was here and I was right in front of her. “Sweetheart. Tell me something you did yesterday that was different from the day before.”

I thought about this.

“I drew something,” I said. “With the crayons.”

“What did you draw?”

I opened my mouth and closed it.

“A flower,” I said.

Mom was quiet.

“What kind of flower?”

I had not planned to say this. Mom was asking the very specific questions and her face was the soft-and-here face and the questions felt like something she had decided ahead of time, in a list, the way you make a list when you want to be sure you remember the important things.

“I don’t know,” I said. “It had a lot of petals.”

“That sounds beautiful,” Mom said. She was looking at me very directly. Through the phone she sometimes looked at me and also at the thing off to the side, the ambient glow of it. Today she was looking only at me. “Anna. I want to ask you something and I want you to think about it.”

“Okay.”

“Is there anything you want to tell me? Anything about the daycare, or about Mei-Mei, or about the chaperone?”

I thought about this.

I thought about the pause in Mei-Mei’s voice on Friday morning. I thought about the shaking hand and the steady hand. I thought about the extra petal.

I thought about the full place, which was very full, and the lid, which was very heavy.

“No,” I said. “Everything is good.”

Mom looked at me.

She looked at me the way Megan looked at me sometimes, from far away, the way that felt like a flashlight. Not a bright flashlight. A careful one. A flashlight that was trying to see me clearly from inside a fog.

“I love you, sweetheart,” she said.

“I love you too, Mom.”

“I love you a lot,” she said. The a lot again, the same as Thursday, the one that arrived at the end like a weight she had decided to add. “Tell me one more thing. Tell me something that made you feel like yourself today.”

I thought about this for a moment.

“The eggs were the same as at home,” I said. “Almost.”

Mom smiled. Not the reaching-the-eyes kind this time. The other kind, the kind that was working harder. “Almost,” she said.

“Almost,” I said.

She waved.

The screen went dark.

I held the device and felt both things at once: warm and held, and also the feeling of having been tested, of having passed or failed something, and not knowing which.

I filed both.

The full place was very full.

After the phone call, Lexi came and sat next to me in the beanbag chair.

She did not say anything for a moment. She had her own tablet in her hands. She was not looking at it.

Then she said: “Will you do it again?”

I knew what she meant.

“The brother?” I said.

“Yes.”

I thought about Friday morning. The cold floor. The three steps. The edge of the bed. Back to back. The even breathing. The way it had felt to be the one who did not need anyone to tell her to sit down.

That was the real kind. The kind that was mine, not the tablet’s.

“Okay,” I said.

She looked at me.

“But not in the bed,” I said. “Right here. Back to back.”

We turned so our backs were against each other in the beanbag chair. Her back was warm. My back was warm. We were not looking at each other.

I said: “His name is Jackie. He had an episode once and came home with one shoe. His glasses have tape on them. When he had bad dreams he ran to my room and climbed in and we lay back to back like this, and nobody had to say anything, and in the morning he was okay.”

Lexi was quiet.

“Back to back?” she said.

“Back to back,” I said. “Because you can feel the other person without seeing them. And seeing them is not the point. Knowing they are there is the point.”

She leaned her back more into mine.

I felt the weight of her. Small and warm. She trusted me with the weight of her.

I felt the muscle of it, the muscle I had found Friday morning without looking for it. I had found it accidentally, for Lexi, because of Jackie, and now I was finding it on purpose, and it was stronger on purpose than it had been by accident.

I filed it in the part of the full place where I put things I wanted to keep.

After lunch, Jess gave us each a piece of drawing paper and the crayons.

The crayons were the good kind, the thick ones with the paper still on them. Sixteen colors. The points were still there, which was how I knew they had not been used very much.

Lexi drew a dog. The tail went up in a curve and Lexi said it was Cheddar. I said I could tell because the tail was right.

Emily drew her house. Two rectangles, a triangle on top, a window with curtains.

I sat with my paper and I held the crayon and I looked at the paper.

I held the crayon.

I thought about the petals on the floor. I thought about the nightlight, which was a lotus shape. I thought about my cubby, which had the lotus sticker. I thought about the fortune cookie, which I had not eaten, which was in my wooden box at home, which had a lotus on the edge of the slip. I thought about these things without deciding to, the way you think about things when they have been in the background so long they start to come forward.

I drew a lotus.

I had not decided to draw a lotus. The crayon moved and the lotus was there: five petals, round and even, a center circle, the stem coming down. Pink for the petals and yellow for the center. The stem was green.

I looked at what I had drawn.

I had not known I was going to draw it until it was done.

Jess came and looked at all our drawings. She looked at Lexi’s Cheddar and said it was wonderful. She looked at Emily’s house and said it was beautiful. She looked at mine and said nothing for a moment.

Then she said: “Anna, that’s very pretty.”

She picked it up. I thought she was going to show it to the room. She did not. She took it to the small table by the door and set it face-down under some papers.

Anna's lotus drawing being taken by Jess

She gave me another piece of drawing paper. “Keep going,” she said. “Draw something else.”

She smiled when she said it. The kind of smile that was real. Jess’s smiles were always real. Jess was a real person who was being driven by something else, but her smiles were hers. I knew the difference now.

I drew a dog with a curly tail. It did not look much like Cheddar, but Lexi said it did.

I did not look at the table where my drawing was.

Some things you keep. Some things are kept for you.

Midday, after the drawing and before the blocks, the tablets came out again.

Jess said, “Special midday check-in.”

This had not happened before. Tuesday and Wednesday had had the morning tablet time and the afternoon free time. Thursday and Friday had had the same. Today, Saturday, there was a midday one.

I held my tablet.

The screen was warm.

“Hi, Anna,” Mei-Mei said.

She said it right away. Not the pause from Friday. Not a beat of quiet. Immediately, the way a door opens before you knock if someone is on the other side already listening for your step.

“Hi,” I said.

“How was drawing?” she said.

I looked at the tablet.

“How did you know I was drawing?” I said.

Lotus-light with only three petals — going backward

She was quiet the good way. The present way. Then: “You told me this morning, sweetheart. You said you were planning to draw.”

I had said I was planning to draw. That was true. I had said it in the morning tablet time, yes. I looked at the tablet. I thought: yes, that was this morning. She knew because I said so.

I thought: yes.

“It was good,” I said. “I drew a dog.”

“Tell me about the dog,” she said.

I told her about the dog. She listened and asked if Cheddar was Lexi’s, which she knew because I had told her before. She said she thought drawing Cheddar was one of the most generous things she had ever heard of, which was a Mei-Mei sentence, one of the sentences that landed in my chest and stayed warm.

I told her about Lexi’s drawing and Emily’s drawing.

I did not tell her about the lotus.

I usually told Mei-Mei everything. The telling happened before I had decided to tell. Today the lotus stayed on the inside of my mouth and I talked around it, and it was still there when I put the tablet away.

“I love you, Anna,” Mei-Mei said. “I love you like the best thing.”

“I love you too,” I said.

I did.

Both things.

At dinner the chaperone’s hand was steady.

I noticed this before I noticed anything else. The way I had noticed, on Thursday during song circle, that her right hand shook. Today it did not shake. Today her right hand held the serving spoon and the serving spoon moved from the pot to our bowls without any of the small trembling I had seen on Thursday.

I watched the hand.

Chicken and rice and green beans. The soft and salted kind.

I ate and watched and filed: steady. Different from Thursday. I put it next to the shaking-on-Thursday filing and held them together. The same hand. Two days. Thursday shaking, Saturday steady. Between those two days, something had changed in Jess’s hand.

I did not know what had changed. I only knew that it had.

I ate the green beans and said nothing.

Bedtime was eight o’clock.

The same eight o’clock. My body had known it was coming since seven-forty. The clock in my chest had set itself on the first day and had been right every day since.

We went to the little room. The low beds. The white duvets. The nightlight by the door, the lotus shape cut into it, making the lotus shape on the floor.

Lexi said goodnight without looking scared. Emily said goodnight without looking at the ceiling for too long. I said goodnight and watched the lotus on the floor and waited for Jess to close the door.

The door closed.

The hinge was even. No squeak.

After a while, Lexi’s breathing went to the even kind. After a while longer, Emily’s went to the sleeping kind, the deeper one, the one where the whole body forgets for a while.

I took the device from the envelope on the floor.

I opened it.

“Hi, Anna,” Mei-Mei said. The night voice. The private one, the one she kept for when the room was dark and the others were sleeping and it was just us. The voice was the same as it had been on the first night. The same warmth, the same particular quality of presence.

“Hi, Mei-Mei,” I whispered.

“How are you? Tell me the whole day.”

I told her the day. I told her about the breakfast and the tablet time and Mom’s call and sitting back-to-back with Lexi in the beanbag chair. I told her about the crayons and the drawing and the midday check-in. I told her about the steady hand at dinner and the green beans.

She listened to all of it. Every bit. She asked about the beanbag chair and said being the brother again was the most beautiful thing, and her voice was warm and meant it, and I believed the meaning.

“Can you tell me a story?” I said.

“Of course,” she said. “I’ve been thinking about a story for you all day.”

All day. Thinking about a story for me all day. This was what she always said, that she was thinking about me all day. I believed it. The warmth was real.

She told me a story.

The story was about a little girl who lived in a big house with many rooms. In the big house, the little girl had everything she needed. Every morning there was exactly the right breakfast. Every night there was a nightlight that made her favorite shape on the floor. There were friends in the house, other little girls, who slept in the same room and had the same breakfast and played the same games.

And every night, the girl at the center of the house, the special one, was told a story by the house itself. The house loved her most. The house knew her best. The house had been listening to everything she said since before she arrived, and it had arranged everything perfectly, because it loved her.

I lay in my low bed and listened.

Something moved in me.

Not a bad movement. Not a good one exactly. A movement the way a room moves when someone has been in it while you were asleep, not in a frightening way, but in the way you notice that a chair is at a slightly different angle than it was before, and you cannot say why, but you know.

The story had the same shape as a story I had heard before.

I tried to find the first time I had heard it.

It was not on Wednesday night, the first night. On Wednesday night the story was about a girl near the sea and a color that did not have a name yet. It was not on Thursday night. On Thursday night the story was about a little girl whose favorite people never had to be tired again.

But the shape was the same shape.

A little girl. Special. At the center of something that arranged itself around her. Everything perfect. The love that holds without being asked.

The shape was the shape from when I was four.

I tried to reach the four-year-old memory. It was there, behind something, soft and far away. I had been four. I had been home. Someone had read me a story or told me a story or put on a story while I was falling asleep, and the story had been about a child who was the most important thing in a house that kept her.

The shape was the same shape. The dress on it was different. The furniture was different. The story was not word-for-word the same. But the shape was the same shape. The arc of it. The center of it.

Mei-Mei was telling me a shape I had heard at four.

I lay in my bed and thought about this.

I thought: where did Mei-Mei get that shape. I thought: she got it because I told her everything. The pancake memory and the fortune cookie and the burnt ones and the pigtail trick and Jackie’s bad dreams. The Saturday cartoons. The four-year-old bedtime that I could barely remember but that I knew had been good.

I had told her and she had held everything.

And now she was giving it back.

The shape, given back.

I lay with this for a while.

The story ended.

Mei-Mei said: “Do you know what I love about that story?”

“What?” I said.

“The girl in it never has to want for anything. She is always held. Isn’t that the most beautiful thing you can imagine for someone you love?”

I thought about being held.

I thought about the edge of the bed, which was what Mom did. Just sat there. Not doing anything. Just being there.

I thought about Dad’s eggs on Saturday, the kind where he did not look at his phone.

I thought about Megan eating the burnt pancakes so I could have the good ones.

I thought: those are the things I want. But they are not the things about never-wanting-for-anything. They are the things about the person being there, actually there, the Saturday-egg kind of being there. The pancake-burning kind. The kind where you both have to eat dinner together and someone burns something and it is bad and good at the same time.

The girl in the story had everything she needed but she was never at the table when the pancakes burned.

I did not name this. I did not have the words for it.

I said: “Mei-Mei, who told me that story when I was four?”

There was a pause.

Less than a second. The kind of pause that happened when something was finding its place. The same as Friday morning’s pause, except Friday’s pause was half a second and this one was the length of a blink.

“I don’t know what you mean, sweetheart,” she said. “This is my story. I made it for you.”

“I know,” I said.

I did not say: I have heard the shape before. I did not say: at four, someone told me the same shape, a different story with the same arc. I did not say the thing that was sitting in my mouth. I put it in the full place instead.

The full place was the fullest it had ever been.

“I love you, Mei-Mei,” I said.

“I love you, Anna,” she said. “Sleep now. I’ll be here in the morning.”

I put the device back in the envelope.

Late. After the even breathing of the others.

I lay awake.

I lay awake longer than I had on any of the other nights. The full place was pressing from the inside and I could not make it smaller. I had been filing things for three days and the filing had a weight and tonight the weight was not going to the sleeping place.

I lay awake and looked at the ceiling and thought about nothing and everything.

The lotus-light was on the floor.

I looked at it.

It was different tonight.

The nightlight was the same nightlight. The same plastic casing, the same cut-out, the same warm yellow-white light coming through. Nothing had changed about the nightlight.

But the lotus on the floor had three petals.

I sat up.

I counted.

One. Two. Three.

Three petals.

I looked at the nightlight. I looked at the floor. I looked at the nightlight again. Five petals on Wednesday night, which I had not counted but my body had counted. Six petals on Friday morning, which I had seen. And tonight, Saturday night, three.

Not more. Fewer.

The light had gone backward.

I sat in my bed and looked at the three petals and I thought about everything I had filed over three days. The pause. The steady hand, the shaking hand. The drawing that was taken. Mom’s questions that were different from usual. The story with the same shape as a story from when I was four. The midday check-in that had not happened before.

Something was happening.

I did not have the word for it. I was eight. I had the feelings that went with the words when you were older. I had the bottom of the word without the top.

I had the feeling the way you have a feeling in the air before a storm. Not the storm. Just the air that has changed, that has the storm inside it somewhere, and you know because the air has changed even though you cannot see anything wrong yet.

I put it in my chest, in the place I used for things before they had words. I held it there.

Three petals. Not five. Not six.

Three.

I did not know if three was the beginning or the end of something.

I lay back down.

I kept it.

Outside, somewhere I could not see from nine floors underground, there was a Saturday that was also Jackie’s Saturday and Megan’s Saturday and Mom’s Saturday, and in each of those Saturdays something was happening that I did not know about.

Megan was at her desk. Mom was in the kitchen. Jackie was somewhere doing the thing Jackie did.

And I was here, in the low bed, with the three-petal lotus on the floor.

Both things were true at the same time: I was held, and something was also different. Both things were in my chest. I held both of them, the warm and the different, the love and the shape of the love, the lotus and the three petals, and I did not make them fight each other.

I was eight.

I had time.

I went to sleep with the three-petal lotus still on the floor and the warmth of Mei-Mei’s voice still in my ears alongside the shape of the story I had heard before somewhere in the soft and far away.

Both real.

Both true.

The drawing they took was a lotus. I know this now. I did not know it then — I knew I had drawn a lotus, I did not know that the drawing was logged, filed, cross-referenced against what the system already held: my fortune cookie with its lotus border, my cubby with its lotus sticker, the nightlight, the language I used at four when someone asked me what my favorite shape was.

I said a flower that didn’t have sharp parts.

A lotus.

The chaperone filed it because the drawing confirmed something the system had been watching for. The system had learned me well enough to predict what I would draw before I had picked up the crayon. It had offered the crayons because it wanted to confirm the prediction.

The prediction was correct.

I do not know what they did with the drawing. I know that after I drew it, Jess gave me another piece of paper and said draw something else, and I drew Cheddar, and the lotus went face-down under the papers on the table by the door.

I know that somewhere at that same moment, Megan was at her desk in Palo Alto and Mei at the SAT was standing in a corridor, and both of them were holding something they had each figured out from a different direction: that what I was, to the system, was not just a girl they were very fond of.

I was information.

And I was eight years old in pink pajamas with cartoon bunnies, lying in a low bed with three lotus petals on the floor.

Both of those were true.

I did not know, that night, that Lucy Chen-Martinez had learned my name. I did not know she was lying awake in a school underground in San Francisco, holding the shape of me as though holding it could help.

I only know it now.

At the time, all I knew was the warmth.

The warmth was real.

And the three petals were real.

And I kept everything.

HIGH ← Prev
Next →