CONCEPT

The Winners' History of Technology

Merritt Roe Smith's diagnosis of how technological transitions are typically narrated—as clean progressive stories centered on the gains of the empowered, written without the voices of the displaced—producing a distortion that serves the winners' interests by erasing the costs that determined the transition's true character.

The winners' history of technology is Merritt Roe Smith's name for the dominant narrative mode through which technological transitions are recorded and transmitted. It is the history written by the people who built the machines, funded the research, owned the patents, and profited from the deployment—a history in which innovation is triumphant, progress is linear, and the only figures who appear as obstacles are figures whose resistance is treated as irrational before being forgotten. The craftsmen who broke frames in Nottinghamshire in 1812 appear, if they appear at all, as speed bumps on the road to industrial modernity. The workers at Harpers Ferry who resisted precision manufacturing for a decade appear as conservative resisters to inevitable progress. Their skills, their knowledge, their sophisticated understanding of what the reorganization would cost—none of this enters the standard narrative. The winners write the history. The losers are written out of it.

Keep reading with YOU ON AI