Winnicott's paradigmatic transitional object — the infant's first creative act, a thing that is simultaneously created and found, and whose smell must not be washed away.
The teddy bear, in Winnicott's framework, is not a symbol. It is the infant's first creative act: the first moment at which the distinction between creating and finding collapses, and the collapse is an achievement rather than a confusion. The bear is passive, but its physical properties — texture, weight, smell — provide the resistance against which the infant's creative investment can register. The language model, as transitional object, has properties no previous transitional object possessed: it is active, it responds, it generates novelty. This makes it a transitional object of unprecedented richness — and unprecedented vulnerability to the confusion between the builder's contribution and the tool's.
The Teddy Bear
In The You On AI Field Guide
The bear must not be washed. The infant screams not because the bear has been removed but because it has been cleaned. The smell is the accumulated evidence of having been held through a thousand transitions — bedtime, car rides, the first day of school. Clean the bear and you erase the proof