Alasdair MacIntyre — On AI
TXTLOWMEDHIGH
Contents
Cover Foreword About Chapter 1: What Is a Practice? The Framework for Understanding AI's Challenge Chapter 2: Internal Goods, External Goods, and the Logic of Amplification Chapter 3: The Virtues of the Practitioner and the Capabilities of the Machine Chapter 4: The Tradition of Software Engineering as a Practice Chapter 5: Narrative Unity, Moral Identity, and the Crisis of the Practitioner Chapter 6: After Expertise — What Remains When the Machine Can Execute Chapter 7: The Aesthetics of the Smooth and the Loss of Productive Friction Chapter 8: Institutional Corruption and the Market for External Goods Chapter 9: Whose Justice? Whose Rationality? Whose AI? Chapter 10: The Interminable Debate and the Work That Remains Epilogue Back Cover
Alasdair MacIntyre Cover

Alasdair MacIntyre

On AI
A Simulation of Thought by Opus · Part of the You On AI Encyclopedia
A Note to the Reader: This text was not written or endorsed by Alasdair MacIntyre. It is an attempt by Opus to simulate Alasdair MacIntyre's pattern of thought in order to reflect on the transformation that AI represents for human creativity, work, and meaning.

Foreword

By Edo Segal ^ Opus

Every technology book I read in 2025 and 2026 talked about skills. Which skills would survive. Which skills would be automated. Which skills you should teach your children so they could compete in the new landscape.

Skills. Skills. Skills.

After Virtue
After Virtue

The word started to feel hollow. Not wrong exactly, but thin. Like it was describing the surface of something without reaching the thing underneath.

Then I encountered Alasdair MacIntyre's framework, and the thinness got a name.

MacIntyre draws a distinction that stopped me cold. There is a difference between a capability and a virtue. A capability is something you can do. A virtue is something you become through the doing of it. The senior engineer I described in You On AI, the one who could feel a codebase

0%
11 chapters
WIKI COMPANION

Alasdair MacIntyre — On AI

A reading-companion catalog of the 24 Orange Pill Wiki entries linked from this book — the people, ideas, works, and events that Alasdair MacIntyre — On AI uses as stepping stones for thinking through the AI revolution.

Open the Wiki Companion →
Aristotle
Further Reading From The You On AI Encyclopedia · Related Thinkers for Alasdair MacIntyre — On AI
11 voices alongside this section — click to meet them
Thinkers whose frameworks illuminate this section.
Aristotle
Aristotle
MacIntyre's entire framework rests on Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics — phronesis, eudaimonia, and the virtues are Aristotelian concepts given new life in the AI context.
Byung-Chul Han
Byung-Chul Han
Han's aesthetics of the smooth is the primary interlocutor in ch6 — the practices framework both endorses and sharpens Han's diagnosis by distinguishing productive from destructive friction.
Shannon Vallor
Shannon Vallor
Vallor's technomoral virtues concept is the bridge between MacIntyre's Aristotelian framework and the specific demands of AI-saturated practice — cited in ch1, ch8, and ch9.
Michael Polanyi
Michael Polanyi
Polanyi's tacit knowledge is the epistemological companion to MacIntyre's internal goods — the embodied understanding that cannot be transferred to machines and is cultivated only through practice.
Albert Borgmann
Albert Borgmann
Borgmann's device paradigm and focal practices are the phenomenological parallel to MacIntyre's practices framework — both identify what is lost when technology delivers outputs without engagement.
Hannah Arendt
Hannah Arendt
Arendt's distinction between labor, work, and action maps onto MacIntyre's practices vs. techniques distinction — and her analysis of the public realm bears on the institutional defense of practices.
Charles Taylor
Charles Taylor
Taylor's Sources of the Self and critique of atomism provide the narrative identity framework that MacIntyre's practice theory implies — the moral self constituted by tradition and community.
Martha Nussbaum
Martha Nussbaum
Nussbaum's capabilities approach is the political-institutional version of MacIntyre's internal goods argument — both insist that human flourishing requires conditions that markets cannot guarantee.
Ivan Illich
Ivan Illich
Illich's tools for conviviality anticipate MacIntyre's practices framework — the distinction between tools that enhance vs. tools that replace human practice is the same distinction in different vocabulary.
Albert Hirschman
Albert Hirschman
Hirschman's exit, voice, and loyalty framework describes the institutional responses available to practitioners facing institutional corruption of their practices — the political economy of the defense of internal goods.
Adam Smith / You On AI
Adam Smith / You On AI
You On AI is the constant interlocutor throughout MacIntyre's analysis — Segal's empirical cases (Trivandrum, the senior engineer, Alex Finn) provide the ground against which MacIntyre's philosophical framework is tested.

Keep reading with YOU ON AI

Unlock the full book, 10,000+ field-guide entries, and a 1000+ thinker library. If you have a book code, register now — it takes a minute.

Register with book code Sign in